Num stultum est mortem (=Le renvoi)

Composers
Genres Chanson, Contrafactum, Motet
Cycles
Le renvoi d'un coeur esgaré (Secular)

Attribution Note

A-Wn Mus.Hs. 18832 is untexted, but a fully-texted version appears in the "Diphona amoena et florida" of 1549, where it is attributed to "PYRSON DE LARUE." This source is well after the death of both Pierre de la Rue and Loyset Compére. The duo also appears as "Le renvoye" in D-Mbs 260.

The first voice is essentially the same as the top part in Compére's 3-voice "Le renvoy dung cueur" (down an octave), and the first 6 notes of the lower voice match those of the tenor in Compére's rondeau (also down an octave). The rest of the lower voice is quite different, so may have been written by La Rue, or another. (WG Kempster)

Appears in

Source Source Date Location Source Attribution Voices
D-Mbs Mus. MS 260 1539-50 32v–33 La Rue
Voice: [no designation]
Voice Text: Le renvoye [d'ung cueur esgaré]
A-Wn Mus.Hs. 18832 (Upper Voice) ca. 1521-1525 40–40v -
Voice: [no designation]
Voice Text: Num stultum est mortem
A-Wn Mus.Hs. 18832 (Lower Voice) c. 1515-34 40–40v -
Voice: [no designation]
Voice Text: Num stultum est mortem