niels berentsen
Monday, 10 June, 2024
DIAMM (and Haring&Boeke 2021) list the fragmentary, presumably textless, piece on fol. 1v as a concordance of "Ich sach den meyen" in CZ-Pu XI E 9 (and F-Str 222). Strohm (1984) pointed to similarities between these pieces, and concluded the version in CZ-Pu must have been a "garbled version". On closer inspection these two pieces cannot have been the same: beyond the first three notes the tenor does not concur (compare Haring&Boeke 2021, p. 64) and the cantus has no significant concordances at all.